The Age of Magical Overthinking

Notes on Modern Irrationality by Amanda Montell

What if your inner overthinker could become your biggest ally?

In The Age of Magical Overthinking, Amanda Montell uses a series of razor sharp, deeply funny chapters to unpack the cornucopia of cognitive biases that run rampant in our brains.

SMARTEST TAKEAWAYS
Finding Clarity

1️⃣ Name It to Tame It: Giving your overthinking tendencies a playful identity (like "Chatty Cathy" or "Worried Walter") can help you detach from them. This naming exercise reduces their power and makes them more manageable.

2️⃣ Feelings Aren’t Facts: The book reminds us that emotions, while valid, aren’t always accurate reflections of reality. By questioning the stories we tell ourselves, we can separate what's true from what’s just fear talking.

3️⃣ Permission to Be Imperfect: Striving for perfection feeds overthinking. By embracing imperfection, you create space to experiment, fail, and learn—without the mental spiral.

Amanda Montell, author of ‘The Age of Magical Overthinking’

INSIGHTFUL EXAMPLE
The Halo Effect

In a standout chapter, Montell unpacks the "halo effect," a cognitive bias where we allow a single positive trait of a person—like their charm or appearance—to overshadow more critical evaluations of their character.

Montell uses the example of a global celebrity who, despite questionable actions, continues to receive adoration due to their perceived charisma. She explains how this bias shapes our admiration of public figures and even influences our personal relationships.

By recognizing when we’re falling prey to the halo effect, we can develop a more nuanced view of people and make better decisions in our interactions.

A QUOTE TO REMEMBER
Magical Thinking

“Broadly, magical thinking describes the belief that one’s internal thoughts can affect external events.”

Amanda Montell, The Age of Magical Overthinking

BOOK FACTS
The Age of Magical Overthinking

  • Publication date: April 9, 2024

  • Print length: 272 pages

  • Listening length: 6:05

  • Ratings: 4.1 Amazon, 3.5 Goodreads

AUTHOR’S NEW PODCAST
Magical Overthinkers

SlightlySMARTER+COMING SOON! Be the first to know about new products from Slightly Smarter. Join the waitlist and help inform where we focus next.

WHAT’S MAKING US SMARTER
Top Picks for the New Year

  • 2025 Goal Planner: Achieve more in 2025. Set your goals, measure progress, and track your daily tasks in one place. Get yours today.

  • The Art of Reading: Consistently find books you love, read 25-50+ books a year, and learn a note-taking system (so you remember the gold). Take the course.

  • NOAN: The ultimate business partner of entrepreneurs. Try NOAN for free.

Help Us Get Slightly Smarter

How did you like today's email?

Login or Subscribe to participate in polls.